Creative learning assessment
“Different initiatives that exist to measure creativity at the aggregate level are, indeed, not measuring creativity levels per se. They are measuring the contextual characteristics that could be associated with creativity, or the different aspects in society that can be regarded as the output of a creative process (such an innovation). The different sets of indicators, therefore, constitute pointers of aspects that can be related to creativity.” (Villalba, 2009:6).
2 The CLA - Creative Learning Assessment
Note: CLA also stands for
- Collegiate Learning Assessment (see below), a test popular in the USA.
- Communicative Language Ability scale
2.1 The CLA observation framework
“The CLA observation framework allows teachers space to record what they are noticing while children are working on a creative project. It asks questions like: ‘In what ways are children able to take risks and experiment in their learning?’, ‘Do they generate ideas, questions and make connections?’, ‘Are there examples of responding to and commenting on their own and other people’s work?’” (Ellis 2009:319).
Ellis: (2009:318) provide an example observation grid including each of the six creativity contexts. If we understood right, these items are not standardized and can be expanded or adapted to context.
- (i) confidence, independence, enjoyment, e.g.
- developing pleasure and enjoyment
- engagement and focus
- empathy and emotional involvement
- (ii) collaboration and communication, e.g.
- works effectively in a team
- contributes to discussion, makes suggestions
- listens and responds to others
- perseveres, overcomes problems
- communicates and presents ideas
- (iii) creativity, e.g.
- is imaginative and playful
- generates ideas, questions and makes connections
- risk-takes and experiments
- expresses own creative ideas using a range of artistic elements
- (iv) strategies and skills, e.g.
- identifies issues and explores options
- plans and develops a project
- demonstrates a growing range of artistic/creative skills
- uses appropriate subject specific skills with increasing control
- (v) knowledge and understanding, e.g.
- awareness of different forms, styles, artistic and cultural
- traditions, creative techniques
- uses subject specific knowledge and language with
- (vi) reflection and evaluation, e.g.
- responds to and comments on own and others’ work
- responds to artistic/creative experiences
- analyses and constructively criticises work
2.2 The CLA scale
- Level 1: Children play with creative materials and elements and use them to express feelings and ideas. They practise simple skills, exploring possibilities. Children begin to recognise and describe some creative effects. They describe what they think and feel about their own.(Ellis, 2009b)
- Level 5: Children are increasingly conscious of the imaginative possibilities in a particular creative medium. They select and organise their material to express their ideas and intentions, making choices for different purposes and to create different effects. They use skills with precision, control and fluency, combining them appropriately and effectively. Children analyse how meanings are conveyed, with increasing critical awareness, drawing on their knowledge and understanding of an art form and using appropriate vocabulary. They reflect critically on their own and others’ work and show awareness of purpose and context in refining. (Ellis, 2009b)
3 The CLA - Collegiate Learning Assessment
“The Collegiate Learning Assessment (CLA) is a performance assessment of college students’ critical thinking, analytic reasoning, and problem solving and written communication skills. Developed by a group of academics with the Council for Aid to Education (CAE), the CLA assesses the “value added” by an institution to key higher order skills of its students.”(Hafner, 2007).
The assessment includes two tasks:
- “The first type of test is a performance task that asks students to use a set of critical thinking, analytical reasoning, problem solving and written communication skills to answer open-ended question about a task or situation. The task includes a document library with a range of sources (e.g. letters, memos, articles, photos, charts, etc). Students are asked to use their materials in preparing and answering the performance task within 90 minutes. In the task, students are expected to present ideas clearly and to cite sources in the document library that support the points.” (Hafner, 2007).
- “The other type of test is an analytic writing task. Two types of essay prompts are possible, “make an argument” or “critique an argument”. Both tasks measure a student’s ability to articulate ideas, examine claims, support ideas with reasons and examples, sustain a coherent discussion and use standard written English. Students are given 45 minutes to either address an issue in making an argument or critique an argument.”(Hafner, 2007).
- Measuring Creativity: the book (PDF chapters of the "Can creativity be measured?" conference organized by the EC, Brussels, May 28-29,).
- Craft, A. (2005). Creativity in Schools. Tensions and Dilemmas. Abingdon: Routledge.
- Craft, A. 2005; Craft, A., Burnard, P. and Grainger, T. (2005), Progression in Creative Learning (PICS) Open University Press.
- DCMS (2002). Creative Partnerships Mission Statement. London: DCMS.
- DfES (2003). Excellence and Enjoyment: a strategy for primary schools. London: DfES.
- DfES (2005). Every Child Matters. London: HMSO.
- Eisner, E. (2000). The Arts and the Creation of Mind. New Haven, CT: Yale University Press.
- Ellis, Sue (2009), Creative Learning Assessment (CLA): a framework for developing and assessing children’s creative learning, in Proceeding of "Can creativity be measured?", Brussels, May 28-29, 2009. PDF
- Ellis, Sue (2009b), Slides (PDF)
- Ellis, S., Barrs, M. and Bunting, J. (2007). Assessing Communication and Learning in Creative Contexts. London: CLPE/CfBT
- Florida, R. (2002a) The rise of the creative class... And how it’s transforming work, leisure, community and everyday life. New York: Basic Books.
- Florida, R. (2002b), The economic geography of talent, Annals of the Association of American Geographers, 92 (4), pp. 743-755.
- Florida, R. (2002c). Bohemia and economic geography, Journal of Economic geography 2:55-71.
- Florida, R. (2004) The rise of the creative class... And how it’s transforming work, leisure, community and everyday life. 2nd edition. New York: Basic Books.
- Lubart, T. (May, 2009). The multivariate model an its measurement implications. Proceedings of “Can creativity be measured”, 28-29 May, Brussels, Belgium.
- Hafner, Anne L. (2007). Using the Collegiate Learning Assessment (CLA) to Inform Campus Planning, CSULA, PDF
- Robinson, Ken. (June, 2006). Do schools kill creativity? Talk at the TED: Ideas worth spreading conference. HTML/Video, text transcript
- Robinson, Ken (2001). Out of Our Minds: Learning to be Creative, 2nd edition, Capstone. ISBN 1841121258.
- Runco, M. A. (2007). Creativity. Theories and Themes: Research, Development and Practice. Amsterdam: Elsevier.
- Runco, M. A. (2009) Divergent thinking. In B. Kerr (Eds.), .Encyclopedia of Giftedness, creativity, and talent. London: Sage Publications.
- Sternberg, R. J. (2006). The nature of creativity, Creativity Research Journal, 18 (1), 87-98.
- Sternberg, R. J. and Lubart, T. I. (1999), The concept of creativity: Prospects and Paradigms. In R.J. Sternberg (ed.) Handbook of Creativity, pp. 3-16. London: Cambridge University Press.
- Villalba, E. (2008). On Creativity: Towards an Understanding of Creativity and its Measurements. JRC Scientific and Technical Reports, EUR 23561. Luxemburg: Office for Official Publications of the European Communities.
- Villalba, Ernesto (ed) (2009). Proceeding of "Can creativity be measured?", Brussels, May 28-29, 2009.Measuring Creativity: the book (includes all chapters as PDF).
- Villalba, Ernesto (2009). Introduction, Proceeding of "Can creativity be measured?", Brussels, May 28-29, 2009. PDF