Educational program description grid: Difference between revisions

The educational technology and digital learning wiki
Jump to navigation Jump to search
m (Daniel K. Schneider moved page ASPI grid to Educational program description grid)
mNo edit summary
 
(8 intermediate revisions by the same user not shown)
Line 1: Line 1:
== Introduction ==
The grid should help you structure a description of an educational program, e.g. as a planning aid. You can add other criteria or adapt it to your context.


The ASPI (''Analyzing, Sustaining, and Piloting Innovation'') model was developed by Pearay and Jaccaz <ref>PERAYA, Daniel, JACCAZ, Bérénice. Analyser, Soutenir, et Piloter l'Innovation : un modèle “ASPI”. In: TICE 2004. Les TICE ou les Technologies de l'Information et de la Connaissance dans l'Enseignement Supérieur et dans l'Industrie. Université de technologie de Compiègne, 2004. p. 283-289 </ref> in the European Equal project.
(Draft version)
 
{{quotation|It proposes a model, and a vision, that attempts to provide information and scaffolding mainly to university staff but also to policy makers who currently face the initiative of implementing innovation, in all its forms, in the education system. It aims at helping all the different actors, from university managers to university lecturers, involved in the teaching and learning process to answer the following questions: “How do I analyse, guide, and sustain innovation in Higher Education?”, “What kind of information do I need at each stage of the innovation process to make decisions that serve my goals?”, “How do I process the data generated?”, and “How do I feed the results back into the process?”}} (Introduction).
 
== Using the grid ==
It is advisable to describe a project according to this grid as completely as possible. Sections that you cannot fill in should be discussed.
 
The grid should help you structure a description. You can add other criteria or adapt it to your context. In the right column, you find some comments that specify the expected content.
 
Definition: "'''Environment'''" describes the complete learning environment for a given program, e.g. a degree program, a continuous training certificate, an isolated course. It  learning objectives, technical infrastructure, pedagogic strategy, learner evaluation, evaluation etc.
 
== The grid ==


{| class="wikitable"
{| class="wikitable"
|+
|-
|-
| | '''Items'''
| |'''Items'''
|Project description
|'''Project description'''
|-
|-
|'''Structural and organizational variables'''
! colspan="2" |'''Meta Data'''
|-
|Project name
|
|
|-
|-
|1. Can you describe the history of the project ?
|Authors of this document
When was it created and why?
|
|
|-
|-
| | 2. In which structure is the project located?
| Author information
* what dependencies with respect to these structures in terms of constraints, dynamics, etc.?
* A university, an inter-university network?
* Are there partnerships with actors from the economic and social world?
* Does the project rely on existing formal or non-formal, face-to-face or remote networks?
|
|
|-
|-
| | 3. Who do you think are the actors involved?
|Status of the document (Version + date, draft, etc.)
* What are their tasks, functions, roles? Do we have a clear definition of each of these roles and tasks?
* How are the relations between the different actors organised? Do these actors all work in the same structure? If not, in which structures?
* Can you provide a project organization chart and number of people by category?
|
|
|-
|-
|''' Pedagogical aspects '''
|Name of the project
|
|
|-
|-
|Is there a vision statement ?
! colspan="2" |'''Structural and organizational and economic aspects'''
|-
|Can you describe the history of the project ?
 
*When was it created and why?
|
|
|-
|-
|What are the main learning objectives?
| |In which structure is the project located?
*what dependencies with respect to these structures in terms of constraints, dynamics, etc.?
*A university, an inter-university network?
*Are there partnerships with actors from the economic and social world?
*Does the project rely on existing formal or non-formal, face-to-face or remote networks?
|
|
|-
|-
|Is there as preferred pedagogic strategy (or least a preferred type of educational scenario) ?
| |Who do you think are all the actors involved?
*What are their tasks, functions, roles? Do we have a clear definition of each of these roles and tasks?
*How are the relations between the different actors organised? Do these actors all work in the same structure? If not, in which structures?
* Can you provide a project organization chart and number of people by category?
|
|
|-
|-
|Do learners have the opportunity to negotiate their training path?
| |How is the program managed?
 
*By whom?
 
* Can you provide an organigram ?
|
|
|-
|-
|How is the training organized over time? where is the training held?  
| |'''Financial aspects:'''
*What are the financing methods?
* What is its feasibility?
 
* is the project a response to market demands?
* What are the additional costs induced by the project (if it extends or transforms a current project) ?
*What is the breakdown between fixed and variable costs?
*Can the project ultimately be self-financing? If so, in what proportion?
|
|
|-
|-
|What are the human and material resources used? Where do they come from?  
| |''' Individual variables '''
*What are the major characteristics of the different actors, both individually and as a group?
 
*Are their expectations, needs, designs and project supported?
|
|
|-
|-
|What is the nature of the tasks required of the learners?  
| |'''Certification'''
*What type of certification (or not) is used ?
 
*
|
|
|-
|-
|How is collaborative work integrated into the system? Is group work present?  
! colspan="2" |''' Pedagogical aspects '''
|-
|Is there a vision statement ? Can you describe it ?
 
*Can you summarize it or reproduce it ?
|
|
|-
|-
|How is learning assessed?  
|What are the main learning objectives at the program level ?
 
*List the items
*Are they related to a vision statement ?
|
|
|-
|-
|How are technologies used?
|What is the type of program ?
 
*E.g. informal continuous training, formal continuous training,  master program,
|
|
|-
|-
|Is there as preferred pedagogic strategy, instructional design model (or least a preferred type of educational scenario) ? Or several ?
*E.g. Direct instruction, problem-based learning, project-based learning
|
|
|-
| Is there a preferred learning theory ? Or several ?
*E.g. Cognitivsm
|
|
|-
|-
|Do learners have the opportunity to negotiate their training path?
|
|
|-
|How is the training organized over time? where is the training held?
|
|
|-
|-
|What are the human and material resources used?
*E.g. teachers, tutors, advisors
*Are they regular staff or adjuncts / temporary.
*Where do they come from?
|
|
|-
|What types of learning materials exist ?
*Textbooks, online textbooks, online hypertext, video, multimedia presentations, interactive multimedia, ....
* Which are open ?
*Are textbook materials available in several formats, e.g. for offline reading
|
|
|-
|-
|What is the nature of the tasks required from the learners?
*Assignements
*Other participation
*Classes, ....
|
|
|-
|Are learning activities defined as coherent scenarios ?
*If so, are you using some king of design language or templates/forms ?
|
|
|-
|-
| |
|How is collaborative work integrated into the system?  
* Is the scenario explained? What activities are carried out in person and remotely?


*Is group work present?
*Are there collective activities
|
|-
|How is learning assessed?


5. Is there a digital learning environment?
*If yes, are there general guidelines ?
* What features are used? explanation of possible training choices, spaces for communication and collaboration, resource tools; support tools for various types of activities (debates, projects, case studies, research, etc.); group work support tools; support tools for the active participation of learners (social presence, informal communication); reflexivity support tools.
*What is used in different classes ?
|
|-
|What type of learner support exists for courses ? (see also tutoring structure)


*Help Forums ?
*Guidelines ?
*On-boarding activities ?
* Community tools ?
*Instant messaging ?
|
|-
|What activities are carried out in presence and remotely?
|
|-
|What are the particularities related to the practices and culture of the particular subject areas of the program ?
*Tools, procedures, epistemologies, didactics?
|
|-
! colspan="2" |'''Learning environment'''
|-
|List of the technical components (servers) and their version (E.g. Moodle 4.0, Mediawiki 1.35)
|
|-
|What features are used? These are of course related to pedagogic choice.


6. In your system, how does a learner learn to analyze, support and manage innovation?
*spaces for communication and collaboration,
* What resources, what supports do you think are important in your system to support the learning experience of learners?
*resource tools;
*support tools for various types of activities (debates, projects, case studies, research, etc.);
*group work support tools;
*support tools for the active participation of learners (social presence, informal communication);
*reflexivity support tools.
|-
|What place is reserved for distance and how does this relate to presence?
* What are the different constraints due to organizational hybridization?
*What is the share of pedagogical and non-pedagogical tasks in the environment?
*How is the collaboration and division of labor between the actors organized?


*
|
|-
|Is there a formal tutoring structure and activities ?


7. How do you see the consistency (convergence) between objectives, means implemented through the environment, design of the environment and evaluation criteria?
*Is there a teacher ? If so, does he engage in tutoring and how much
* Are there tutors ? How much man power / participant ?
*Other ?
|
|-
!'''Quality assessment, innovation and change management'''
|
|-
| Is there a global quality assessment and innovation strategy ?
|
|-
| Is internal program regulation (self-evaluation and action) formally provided for?
*How does it happen?
*According to what criteria? Is there a quality assessment manual ?
*What changes were already made in the past ?
|
|-
| |
Who participates in quality assessment cycles, in innovation and change processes ?


*Do learners participate ?
*Faculty
*Quality officer(s)
* External agency
*Other ?
|
|-
|How do you see the consistency (convergence) between objectives, means implemented through the program, design of the program and evaluation criteria?


8. How are the interactions between the different actors taken into account?
*Also called alignment
|
|
|-
|-
| |'''Organizational aspects'''
|How are the interactions between the different actors taken into account?
9. How is the environment managed? By whom?


10. What place is reserved for distance and how does this relate to presence?
*Are there bodies where the program (or elements of it) are discussed
* What are the different constraints due to organizational hybridization? What is the share of pedagogical and non-pedagogical tasks in the environment? How is the collaboration and division of labor between the actors organized?
*Who takes decisions ?
|
|-
! colspan="2" |'''Political, cultural, ideological and contextual aspects'''
|-
|Is the project wanted or supported by the political authorities? Institutional? Managers of your companies?


11. Is project regulation (self-evaluation-and-action) provided?
*In what way?
* How does it happen? According to what criteria? What changes were already made to the environment?
*Is it part of an explicit policy?
* Does it respond to a mandate emanating directly from political power?
|
|
|-
|-
| |'''Economic aspects'''
|Cultural factors
12. What are the financing methods? What is its feasibility?
 
* is the project a response to market demands? What are the additional costs induced by the project? What is the breakdown between fixed and variable costs? Can the project ultimately be self-financing? If so, in what proportion?
*Are there social or cultural practices that constrain program design ?
*What socio-linguistic practices does the program have to consider ?
|
|
|-
|-
| |'''Disciplinary aspects'''
|Regulatory environment
13. What are the particularities related to the practices and culture of the field?
 
* Tools, procedures, epistemologies, didactics?
* What are the factors that could enable or hinder program development and implementation ?
|
|
|-
|-
| |'''Political aspects'''
| |What values ​​does the program promote?
14. Is the project wanted or supported by the political authorities? Institutional? Managers of your companies?
*what type of knowledge is promoted by the program?
* In what way? Is it part of an explicit policy? Does it respond to a mandate emanating directly from political power?
*What type of citizen do we want to form?
|
|
|-
|-
| |'''Ideological aspects'''
|<add specific HEiE variables here>
15. What values ​​does the environment promote?
* what type of knowledge is promoted by the environment? What type of citizen do we want to form? For example, what is the reason for such an interest for collaboration today?
|
|
|-
|-
| |''' Individual variables '''
! colspan="2" |''' To conclude… '''
16. What are the major characteristics of the different actors, both individually and as a group? Are their expectations, needs, designs and project supported?
|
|-
|-
| |''' To conclude… '''
|How would you qualify your system and its role in your professional context?
17. How would you qualify your system and its role in your professional context?
*Does it correspond to what is being done in this context? Is it innovative? If so, in what aspects?
* Does it correspond to what is being done in this context? Is it innovative? If so, in what aspects?
*What aspects are innovative for you in your role?
* What aspects are innovative for you in your role?
|
|
|-
|-
|}
|}
 
----
== Links ==
 
<references/>

Latest revision as of 16:16, 19 October 2022

The grid should help you structure a description of an educational program, e.g. as a planning aid. You can add other criteria or adapt it to your context.

(Draft version)

Items Project description
Meta Data
Project name
Authors of this document
Author information
Status of the document (Version + date, draft, etc.)
Name of the project
Structural and organizational and economic aspects
Can you describe the history of the project ?
  • When was it created and why?
In which structure is the project located?
  • what dependencies with respect to these structures in terms of constraints, dynamics, etc.?
  • A university, an inter-university network?
  • Are there partnerships with actors from the economic and social world?
  • Does the project rely on existing formal or non-formal, face-to-face or remote networks?
Who do you think are all the actors involved?
  • What are their tasks, functions, roles? Do we have a clear definition of each of these roles and tasks?
  • How are the relations between the different actors organised? Do these actors all work in the same structure? If not, in which structures?
  • Can you provide a project organization chart and number of people by category?
How is the program managed?
  • By whom?
  • Can you provide an organigram ?
Financial aspects:
  • What are the financing methods?
  • What is its feasibility?
  • is the project a response to market demands?
  • What are the additional costs induced by the project (if it extends or transforms a current project) ?
  • What is the breakdown between fixed and variable costs?
  • Can the project ultimately be self-financing? If so, in what proportion?
Individual variables
  • What are the major characteristics of the different actors, both individually and as a group?
  • Are their expectations, needs, designs and project supported?
Certification
  • What type of certification (or not) is used ?
Pedagogical aspects
Is there a vision statement ? Can you describe it ?
  • Can you summarize it or reproduce it ?
What are the main learning objectives at the program level ?
  • List the items
  • Are they related to a vision statement ?
What is the type of program ?
  • E.g. informal continuous training, formal continuous training, master program,
Is there as preferred pedagogic strategy, instructional design model (or least a preferred type of educational scenario) ? Or several ?
  • E.g. Direct instruction, problem-based learning, project-based learning
Is there a preferred learning theory ? Or several ?
  • E.g. Cognitivsm
Do learners have the opportunity to negotiate their training path?
How is the training organized over time? where is the training held?
What are the human and material resources used?
  • E.g. teachers, tutors, advisors
  • Are they regular staff or adjuncts / temporary.
  • Where do they come from?
What types of learning materials exist ?
  • Textbooks, online textbooks, online hypertext, video, multimedia presentations, interactive multimedia, ....
  • Which are open ?
  • Are textbook materials available in several formats, e.g. for offline reading
What is the nature of the tasks required from the learners?
  • Assignements
  • Other participation
  • Classes, ....
Are learning activities defined as coherent scenarios ?
  • If so, are you using some king of design language or templates/forms ?
How is collaborative work integrated into the system?
  • Is group work present?
  • Are there collective activities
How is learning assessed?
  • If yes, are there general guidelines ?
  • What is used in different classes ?
What type of learner support exists for courses ? (see also tutoring structure)
  • Help Forums ?
  • Guidelines ?
  • On-boarding activities ?
  • Community tools ?
  • Instant messaging ?
What activities are carried out in presence and remotely?
What are the particularities related to the practices and culture of the particular subject areas of the program ?
  • Tools, procedures, epistemologies, didactics?
Learning environment
List of the technical components (servers) and their version (E.g. Moodle 4.0, Mediawiki 1.35)
What features are used? These are of course related to pedagogic choice.
  • spaces for communication and collaboration,
  • resource tools;
  • support tools for various types of activities (debates, projects, case studies, research, etc.);
  • group work support tools;
  • support tools for the active participation of learners (social presence, informal communication);
  • reflexivity support tools.
What place is reserved for distance and how does this relate to presence?
  • What are the different constraints due to organizational hybridization?
  • What is the share of pedagogical and non-pedagogical tasks in the environment?
  • How is the collaboration and division of labor between the actors organized?
Is there a formal tutoring structure and activities ?
  • Is there a teacher ? If so, does he engage in tutoring and how much
  • Are there tutors ? How much man power / participant ?
  • Other ?
Quality assessment, innovation and change management
Is there a global quality assessment and innovation strategy ?
Is internal program regulation (self-evaluation and action) formally provided for?
  • How does it happen?
  • According to what criteria? Is there a quality assessment manual ?
  • What changes were already made in the past ?

Who participates in quality assessment cycles, in innovation and change processes ?

  • Do learners participate ?
  • Faculty
  • Quality officer(s)
  • External agency
  • Other ?
How do you see the consistency (convergence) between objectives, means implemented through the program, design of the program and evaluation criteria?
  • Also called alignment
How are the interactions between the different actors taken into account?
  • Are there bodies where the program (or elements of it) are discussed
  • Who takes decisions ?
Political, cultural, ideological and contextual aspects
Is the project wanted or supported by the political authorities? Institutional? Managers of your companies?
  • In what way?
  • Is it part of an explicit policy?
  • Does it respond to a mandate emanating directly from political power?
Cultural factors
  • Are there social or cultural practices that constrain program design ?
  • What socio-linguistic practices does the program have to consider ?
Regulatory environment
  • What are the factors that could enable or hinder program development and implementation ?
What values ​​does the program promote?
  • what type of knowledge is promoted by the program?
  • What type of citizen do we want to form?
<add specific HEiE variables here>
To conclude…
How would you qualify your system and its role in your professional context?
  • Does it correspond to what is being done in this context? Is it innovative? If so, in what aspects?
  • What aspects are innovative for you in your role?