Writing tool

The educational technology and digital learning wiki
Revision as of 14:36, 11 January 2007 by Kalli (talk | contribs)
Jump to navigation Jump to search

Draft

Definition

A writing tool is software that helps people to write.

In education, they can be considered as a kind of cognitive tool. See also: professionnal software since some writing tools have been made for and are used by real writers.

Tools

There are many kinds of tools.

  • Any kind of word processor
  • Structured word processors
  • Outlining tools
  • Concept organisation, see: Concept maps
  • On-line collaborative writing tools (such as Wikis or through-the-web editing/storing/sharing à la Writely)
  • Various paper tools and that very popular in classroom teaching (e.g. [1])

Such tools can either be for individual use, for group use (e.g. integrated in a groupware application) or based on social computing, e.g. several social software includes note taking tools.

Effects of writing tools on the writing process

Technological writing tools

Computer supported writing tools provide rich possibilities to enhance written communication.

A review by Ulusoy (2006) outlines some specific effects computer-supported writing environments can have on the writing process.

  • pre-writing and planning processes through the use of outlines, concept maps, CSCL, computer-supported collaborative writing
  • provide prompts and context-specific help throughout the writing process
  • text production may be enhanced by the ability to engage in non-linear note-taking and freeflow text production
  • simplification of the revision process through word-processing functions (spell checking, dictionaries, text editing), and prompts.

Haas (1998) found that those writing with a computerized workstation wrote longer, spent less time planning, generated more text, but at a similar rate as writers using pen and paper. They also spent more time revising and attending to the medium than writers using pen and paper

Planning tools

It is believed that experienced writers are better able to effectively engage in planning their texts and this difference leads to better texts (Bereiter and Scardamalia 1987, Flower & Hayes 1980, Haas 1989), though some studies fail to show a connection between the planning methods and the quality of the text produced (Haas 1989, Isnard & Piolat 1993).

Haas used homogeneously experienced writers whose goal was to produce a quality persuasive text, not to learn about argumentation or about a a particular topic. Paper and pen may particularly favour experienced writers who are topic experts and do not need to search for ideas or engage in any knowledge constituting processes as they can move straight to planning with no need to develop ideas further through the text-generating part of the writing process. The order in which planning, text generation, structuring and revision processes occur during the writing process may vary for writers with different experience and learning styles (see Writing-to-learn. More planning may lead to better texts but not necessarily more learning, assumingif the purpose of the argumentation is to learn rather than simply a writing exercise of skills already developed. If trying to teach argumentation skills through writing then the idea generating activity of freeflow text encouraged by computer-supported argumentation tools is important. Planning can be done at any stage in the writing, catering to many Writing-to-learn#Learning_styles_and_writing learning styles.

The tool used in planning and writing can, however, influence the occurrence of the different writing processes. Isnard & Piolat (1993) found that types of planning can influence the number of ideas generated and the overal structural quality of a written text. Outlining during idea-organization phases resulted in more new ideas being generated than when ideas were organized using a freeflow form or a graphic organizational mode (e.g.: chart, graph, concept map)

Links

Important notice: The initial author of this page (DSchneider) did not test any of these.

Collaborative writing systems

There are dozens of systems, but probably not many of them in use on a large scale.

Outlining and draft building

  • Any outlining mode in word processors

Tools for specific genres

Story writing
  • WriteThis. The tool generates writing exercises, based on a set of keywords and criteria. It can generate characters, locations, items and special rules, and you - the writer - have a specified number of minutes to combine these things into a story.
  • QuickStory 5 (A free version is QuickPlot ) ?
Resume/CV writing
Wordprocessing for writers
  • RoughDraft has features specifically designed for creative writing: novels, short stories, articles, plays and screenplays.
  • yWriter, Story writing software (by Simon Haynes, free)
Argumentation and dialog

Note taking tools

See note taking for conceptual issues and specialized software.

Concept maps

See:

Guidelines

Sometimes guidelines for writing are also called tools, e.g.:

General links

e.g. indexes of writing tools

References

  • Bereiter C., Scardamalia, M. (1987) An Attainable Version of High Literacy: Approaches to Teaching Higher-Order Skills in Reading and Writing. Curriculum Inquiry. Vol. 17. No. 1. pp. 9-30.
  • Flower, L. S. and Hayes, J. R. (1980) The cognition of discovery: defining a rhetorical problem. College Composition and Communication, Vol. 31. pp. 21-32.
  • Haas, C. (1989) Does the Medium Make a Difference? Two Studies of Writing With Pen and Paper and With Computers. HCI, 1989, Volume 4, pp. 149-169
  • Isnard, N., Piolat, A. (1993) The effects of different types of planning on the writing of argumentative text. Centre for Research in Psychology of Cognition, Language and Emotion. University of Provence, Aix en Provence. Accessed June 20, 2005 at pdf
  • Mustafa Ulusoy, (2006). The Role of Computers in the Writing Process. The Turkish Online Journal of Educational Technology - TOJET October 2006, Volume 5, Issue 4, Article 8
Retrieved from "https://edutechwiki.unige.ch/mediawiki/index.php?title=Writing_tool&oldid=9976"