Arnitel: Difference between revisions

The educational technology and digital learning wiki
Jump to navigation Jump to search
mNo edit summary
 
(37 intermediate revisions by the same user not shown)
Line 1: Line 1:
== Introduction ==
== Introduction ==


Arnitel is a [[3D printer filament‎‎]]. It's chemical name is DSM Arnitel Eco. It is also sold under re-branded names like InnoFlex. This elastic plastic is difficult to print since it doesn't stick well to the platform. On the positive side it has some nice properties and it doesn't stink.
[[File:big-owl-keyboard.jpg|thumb|350px|Arnitel OWL (model made by [http://www.thingiverse.com/thing:18218 Cushwa] (Thingiverse link). Print quality is quite bad, but it was my second Arnitel print. I printed it too fast and too hot]]
 
Arnitel is a [[3D printer filament‎‎]]. It's chemical name is DSM Arnitel Eco and it is made by [http://www.dsm.com/products/arnitel/en_US/home.html DSM]. It is also sold under re-branded names like InnoFlex or "Flex Eco" This elastic plastic is difficult to print since it doesn't stick well to the platform. On the positive side it has some nice properties and it doesn't stink.


According to [http://www.dsm.com/products/arnitel/en_US/cases/arnitel-eco.html Arnitel Eco] page, {{quotation|Arnitel® Eco material is a bio-based thermoplastic copolyester (TPE) that delivers high performance with the added benefit of a lower environmental impact. The material is 50% made from renewable resources, based on rapeseed oil instead of mineral oil. Yet…it performs outstandingly for demanding applications ranging from oven pan liners to consumer electronics to sports and leisure, automotive and furniture.}}. [...] {{quotation|The material has a melting point of up to 200°C, making it ideal for applications with peak temperatures close to the melting point. In fact, the material maintains consistent performance across its entire operating temperature from low to high extremes, outperforming other elastomers.}}
According to [http://www.dsm.com/products/arnitel/en_US/cases/arnitel-eco.html Arnitel Eco] page, {{quotation|Arnitel® Eco material is a bio-based thermoplastic copolyester (TPE) that delivers high performance with the added benefit of a lower environmental impact. The material is 50% made from renewable resources, based on rapeseed oil instead of mineral oil. Yet…it performs outstandingly for demanding applications ranging from oven pan liners to consumer electronics to sports and leisure, automotive and furniture.}}. [...] {{quotation|The material has a melting point of up to 200°C, making it ideal for applications with peak temperatures close to the melting point. In fact, the material maintains consistent performance across its entire operating temperature from low to high extremes, outperforming other elastomers.}}
Line 11: Line 13:
Arnitel comes in various variants. It's hardness varies from 40 to 70 Shore D. The names of Arnitel variants (or rebrandings like InnoFlex) reflect that. E.g. "60" has a higher elongation than "40".
Arnitel comes in various variants. It's hardness varies from 40 to 70 Shore D. The names of Arnitel variants (or rebrandings like InnoFlex) reflect that. E.g. "60" has a higher elongation than "40".


; Specifications for printing.
== Specifications for printing ==


Rumours on the Internet vary widely with respect to printing.
Rumours on the Internet vary widely with respect to printing. In sum, it's about the same picture as with ABS printing.


* Nozzle temperature is from 210 to 260. It seems that more elastic Arnitel should printed cooler than lesser elastics (makes sense). Melting temperature is between 180 and 200 (probably).
* Nozzle temperature is from 210 to 260. It seems that more elastic Arnitel should printed cooler than lesser elastic one (makes sense). Melting temperature is between 180 and 200 (probably). I'd say, for starters, go as high as possible and then go down. I settled at 225 degrees for Arnitel Eco 45-D.
* Bed temperature from 55 to 110
* Bed temperature from 55 to 110. The hotter, the better probably since it will stick better. However, too hot temperatures make it expand more and therefore could increase warping. In addition, '''if your printer parts are made with PLA they will bend''' if you heat a lot. (I happened to my Felix Printer after heating the bed to 110 degrees and I had to bend the extruder back with heat gun.... not really optimal)
* Print speed: from 40 to 80 mm/s. Faster is OK since flow isn't a problem with Arnitel, but probably produces less nice results.
* Print speed: from 40 to 80 mm/s. Faster is OK since flow isn't a problem with Arnitel, but fast probably produces less nice results.
* Arnitel warps. You need to use some strong adhesive tape or '''glue''' (e.g. a Pritt Power Stick) if you plan to print more than a few layers with an object that is larger than 2cm. '''Remove the glue''' before you start printing with PLA again.
* Keep the roll stored in plastic (same is true for most filaments ....)
* Keep the roll stored in plastic (same is true for most filaments ....)


I'd say, for starters, go as high as possible.
; In addition
* Your printer should have a hot-end that stays cool at the top (ventilator, heat diffusing tube). Otherwise the plastic will get too weak after some printing and can not be pushed down anymore and will flow out into the extruder. E.g. I can see this happen with the Felix 1.0 but not with the better designed 2.0
* If an object detaches through warping you can fix it with adhesive gum in order to finish a print (stop the printer and take your time).
* In order to have nicer looking results, augment retraction a bit.
 
[[File:owls-arnitel2.jpg|thumb|none|800px|It takes some time to learn it. From left to right: warped, head injury, clogged hot end, belly injury, OK]]
 
=== Printing tips using a Felix 2.0 printer ===
 
Since Arnitel Eco doesn't stick well to the platform (it gets loose once it cools down), you will have to apply the whole bag of tricks:
* Add some sticky tape or some PVA glue stick (e.g. Pritt Power stick) or hairspray with a "plastic base". Alternatively, you could try replacing the Kapton tape of the platform with PET tape. PET tape also seems to work better with ABS.
* Heat the bed as much as you can. In principle you can heat at 95 degrees, but '''do not''' since the heat then may cause the PLA extruder to bend downwards.... If you use glue, then the temperature can be lower.
* Make sure that the print head is very close to the platform (1-2 sheets of paper max.).
* Make the first layer compact (e.g. 75% of the usual height). This is to "press" it down.
* Add a raft (squeezed, underneath and extended at least 1 cm on each side so you can tape it down if gets loose. This will allow for some warping, i.e. the object will warp and pull up parts but not all of the raft and that means no print abort.
* Print slower than for PLA printing, e.g. at 50 - 75% (but not too slow, or the extruder may clog)
* For high and delicate objects, add cooling loops (print circling without printing) or print two objects instead of one.
* Fan should be on for better results. However, since the object will probably warp a bit, turning off the fan will reduce the risk of the nozzle ripping away the part from the print bed. In addition, keeping it on, might cause warping to occur later, since the plastic will keep longer a warm temperature. Therefore: maybe have the fan off for the first 50 layers, after that it's up to you. Definitively use a fan for wide objects with little filling or the whole filling will melt down. I always have the fan on, except if I hear scratching noises ...
* Temperature: 225 (?) ... though some folks seem to print with 205 degrees, other with 250...
* 0.2mm layers, 0.35 width
* 10% fill (or you cannot squeeze your toys ...)
 
[[File:lego-4x2x4-diamonds.png|thumbnail|right|300px|frame|Lego compatible brick with "diamond" holes]]
 
=== Summary of anti-warping strategies ===
 
The bottom line is that you will have to find a '''method to make it stick and avoid geometries that want to warp'''.


== Printing tips ==
It's probably best to use a combination of a hot printbed, some kind of glue and (if possible) a modified geometry.
* If you don't mind an ugly bottom, you also can try printing without glue, but then tape down the draft after it starts detaching....
* consider that you cannot print (I can't at least) all the sorts of objects you could print with PLA. E.g. objects that have a wide bottom plus some height will have a strong urge to warp. Something that is thin (less than 10 layers) ''and'' wide could be done before the print starts warping. If you must print objects that are larger than 2cm and have high walls, consider structural changes. E.g. put holes in the walls that "pull" the object towards its center. To the right is a picture of a modified Lego brick that should reduce warping.


Using a Felix 2.0 printer


* Since Arnitel Eco doesn't stick well to the platform (it gets loose once it cools down), you will have to apply the whole bag of tricks:
[[File:big-owl-gummed.jpg|thumbnail|800px|none|If a larger object starts warping you still can save it by fixing its base with adhesive gum or by taping down the raft. I now systematically put glue on the platform before printing (Pritt Power which is washable at 40 degs)]]
** heat the bed as much as you can, e.g. 90 degrees (however, the bed temperature for Arnitel D-45 rather should be around 110)
** make sure that the print head is very close to the platform (1 sheet of paper),
** Make the first layer compact (e.g. 75% of the usual height). This is to "press" it down.
** You also should add a raft (underneath and extended at least 1 cm, so you can tape it down if gets loose
** Print slower than for PLA printing, e.g. at 50 - 75% (but not too slow, or the extruder may clog)
** Maybe add cooling loops (print circling without printing)
** Add some sticky tape or some PVA glue stick (so far I didn't try since I don't have any at hand, I used adhesive gum instead).
** Fan must be on of course


* Temperature: 220 ? ... though some folks seem to print with 205 degrees, other with 250...
=== Filling ===


* 0.2mm layers
Since Arnitel is very tough and it sticks well together, you can use very little filling. I'd recommend using the fan.


The bottom line is that you will have to find a method to make it stick. It's probably best to use a combination of a very hot printbed and some kind of glue. If you don't mind an ugly bottom, you also can try to print without glue, but then tape down the draft after it starts detaching....
<gallery caption="Printing with Arnitel - 5% fill !" widths="400px" heights="300px">
arnitel-filling-1.jpg|Half spheres in print
arnitel-filling-2.jpg|Filling of half spheres
</gallery>
 
BTW, using a raft for large objects is not necessary, but if you use glue, it's easier to get of the platform that way.


== Alternatives ==
== Alternatives ==


* NinjaFlex and SemiFlex (made by [http://www.fennerdrives.com/ninjaflex3dprinting/_/3d/// Fenner Drives)
* NinjaFlex and SemiFlex (made by [http://www.fennerdrives.com/ninjaflex3dprinting/_/3d/// Fenner Drives])


* Flex filament (?)
* Flex filament (?)


== Links ==
== Links ==
; Tips


* [http://forums.reprap.org/read.php?262,457486 How To Print With InnoFlex ?] (RepRap forums)
* [http://forums.reprap.org/read.php?262,457486 How To Print With InnoFlex ?] (RepRap forums)
* [http://forums.reprap.org/read.php?262,431484,431636 Printing with Arnitel AKA Flexible Polyester] (RepRap forums)
* [http://forums.reprap.org/read.php?262,431484,431636 Printing with Arnitel AKA Flexible Polyester] (RepRap forums)
* [http://forum.felixprinters.com/viewtopic.php?f=7&t=248 Arnitel] (Felix Printer Forum thread)
* [http://forum.felixprinters.com/viewtopic.php?f=7&t=248 Arnitel] (Felix Printer Forum thread)
* [http://www.dsm.com/products/arnitel/en_US/cases/arnitel-eco.html Arnitel Eco] page at DSM (producer)
 
; Product pages and data sheets at DSM
* [http://www.dsm.com/products/arnitel/en_US/home.html Arnitel Eco] product page at DSM (producer)
* [http://www.dsm.com/products/arnitel/en_US/cases/arnitel-eco.html Arnitel Eco] page at DSM
* [http://www.dsm.com/content/dam/dsm/arnitel/en_US/documents/arnitel-eco-brochure.pdf Arnitel Eco - the next generation of bio-performance materials (2.79 MB)]
* [http://www.dsm.com/products/arnitel/en_US/product-info/product-data-sheets.html Product data sheets] (for all variants)
 
; Print bed materials
 
* [https://www.matterhackers.com/articles/how-to-succeed-when-printing-with-abs#abs3 How To Succeed When Printing With ABS] and [http://www.matterhackers.com/articles/printing-tips-&-tricks:-abs-bed-adhesion ABS Bed Adhesion Tips & Tricks] (talks about PET tape and other tricks to have ABS stick. Since ABS problems are similar to Arnitel problems with respect to sticking, it's a good read.)


[[Category: 3D printing]]
[[Category: 3D printing]]

Latest revision as of 18:50, 2 September 2015

Introduction

Arnitel OWL (model made by Cushwa (Thingiverse link). Print quality is quite bad, but it was my second Arnitel print. I printed it too fast and too hot

Arnitel is a 3D printer filament‎‎. It's chemical name is DSM Arnitel Eco and it is made by DSM. It is also sold under re-branded names like InnoFlex or "Flex Eco" This elastic plastic is difficult to print since it doesn't stick well to the platform. On the positive side it has some nice properties and it doesn't stink.

According to Arnitel Eco page, “Arnitel® Eco material is a bio-based thermoplastic copolyester (TPE) that delivers high performance with the added benefit of a lower environmental impact. The material is 50% made from renewable resources, based on rapeseed oil instead of mineral oil. Yet…it performs outstandingly for demanding applications ranging from oven pan liners to consumer electronics to sports and leisure, automotive and furniture.”. [...] “The material has a melting point of up to 200°C, making it ideal for applications with peak temperatures close to the melting point. In fact, the material maintains consistent performance across its entire operating temperature from low to high extremes, outperforming other elastomers.”

According to 3D printing blog, “Arnitel is a high-performance ThermoPlastic Copolyester (TPC) that offers you a unique combination of flexibility, high temperature resistance and strength. Arnitel Eco is manufactured using renewable feedstock, in fact 50% of its content comes from renewable resources, and in particular, rapeseed oil instead of mineral oil. This elastic product outperforms conventional rubbers according to the manufacturer across a variety of applications, and is available in hardnesses ranging from 40 to 70 Shore D. The Arnitel Eco 3D printer filament can be used with any 3D printer that supports PLA filaments as you need to have an extruder temperature of about 230 degrees Celsius for the Arnitel when printing, the same as for PLA.”

Variants

Arnitel comes in various variants. It's hardness varies from 40 to 70 Shore D. The names of Arnitel variants (or rebrandings like InnoFlex) reflect that. E.g. "60" has a higher elongation than "40".

Specifications for printing

Rumours on the Internet vary widely with respect to printing. In sum, it's about the same picture as with ABS printing.

  • Nozzle temperature is from 210 to 260. It seems that more elastic Arnitel should printed cooler than lesser elastic one (makes sense). Melting temperature is between 180 and 200 (probably). I'd say, for starters, go as high as possible and then go down. I settled at 225 degrees for Arnitel Eco 45-D.
  • Bed temperature from 55 to 110. The hotter, the better probably since it will stick better. However, too hot temperatures make it expand more and therefore could increase warping. In addition, if your printer parts are made with PLA they will bend if you heat a lot. (I happened to my Felix Printer after heating the bed to 110 degrees and I had to bend the extruder back with heat gun.... not really optimal)
  • Print speed: from 40 to 80 mm/s. Faster is OK since flow isn't a problem with Arnitel, but fast probably produces less nice results.
  • Arnitel warps. You need to use some strong adhesive tape or glue (e.g. a Pritt Power Stick) if you plan to print more than a few layers with an object that is larger than 2cm. Remove the glue before you start printing with PLA again.
  • Keep the roll stored in plastic (same is true for most filaments ....)
In addition
  • Your printer should have a hot-end that stays cool at the top (ventilator, heat diffusing tube). Otherwise the plastic will get too weak after some printing and can not be pushed down anymore and will flow out into the extruder. E.g. I can see this happen with the Felix 1.0 but not with the better designed 2.0
  • If an object detaches through warping you can fix it with adhesive gum in order to finish a print (stop the printer and take your time).
  • In order to have nicer looking results, augment retraction a bit.
It takes some time to learn it. From left to right: warped, head injury, clogged hot end, belly injury, OK

Printing tips using a Felix 2.0 printer

Since Arnitel Eco doesn't stick well to the platform (it gets loose once it cools down), you will have to apply the whole bag of tricks:

  • Add some sticky tape or some PVA glue stick (e.g. Pritt Power stick) or hairspray with a "plastic base". Alternatively, you could try replacing the Kapton tape of the platform with PET tape. PET tape also seems to work better with ABS.
  • Heat the bed as much as you can. In principle you can heat at 95 degrees, but do not since the heat then may cause the PLA extruder to bend downwards.... If you use glue, then the temperature can be lower.
  • Make sure that the print head is very close to the platform (1-2 sheets of paper max.).
  • Make the first layer compact (e.g. 75% of the usual height). This is to "press" it down.
  • Add a raft (squeezed, underneath and extended at least 1 cm on each side so you can tape it down if gets loose. This will allow for some warping, i.e. the object will warp and pull up parts but not all of the raft and that means no print abort.
  • Print slower than for PLA printing, e.g. at 50 - 75% (but not too slow, or the extruder may clog)
  • For high and delicate objects, add cooling loops (print circling without printing) or print two objects instead of one.
  • Fan should be on for better results. However, since the object will probably warp a bit, turning off the fan will reduce the risk of the nozzle ripping away the part from the print bed. In addition, keeping it on, might cause warping to occur later, since the plastic will keep longer a warm temperature. Therefore: maybe have the fan off for the first 50 layers, after that it's up to you. Definitively use a fan for wide objects with little filling or the whole filling will melt down. I always have the fan on, except if I hear scratching noises ...
  • Temperature: 225 (?) ... though some folks seem to print with 205 degrees, other with 250...
  • 0.2mm layers, 0.35 width
  • 10% fill (or you cannot squeeze your toys ...)
Lego compatible brick with "diamond" holes

Summary of anti-warping strategies

The bottom line is that you will have to find a method to make it stick and avoid geometries that want to warp.

It's probably best to use a combination of a hot printbed, some kind of glue and (if possible) a modified geometry.

  • If you don't mind an ugly bottom, you also can try printing without glue, but then tape down the draft after it starts detaching....
  • consider that you cannot print (I can't at least) all the sorts of objects you could print with PLA. E.g. objects that have a wide bottom plus some height will have a strong urge to warp. Something that is thin (less than 10 layers) and wide could be done before the print starts warping. If you must print objects that are larger than 2cm and have high walls, consider structural changes. E.g. put holes in the walls that "pull" the object towards its center. To the right is a picture of a modified Lego brick that should reduce warping.


If a larger object starts warping you still can save it by fixing its base with adhesive gum or by taping down the raft. I now systematically put glue on the platform before printing (Pritt Power which is washable at 40 degs)

Filling

Since Arnitel is very tough and it sticks well together, you can use very little filling. I'd recommend using the fan.

BTW, using a raft for large objects is not necessary, but if you use glue, it's easier to get of the platform that way.

Alternatives

  • Flex filament (?)

Links

Tips
Product pages and data sheets at DSM
Print bed materials